Much has been written about the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, but how much of it is accurate, and what has been changed over the years? The American entry into World War II that followed sparked frenzy and panic, allowing misinformation to spread quickly. As a result, myths about the surprise attack were created—but what’s the real story?
Here are five myths and the truths behind them.
Pearl Harbor was the only target
A commonly held misconception is that Pearl Harbor was the sole target of the Japanese on December 7, 1941. While it is the most well-known, it was actually one of six targets. On the same day, the Japanese also attacked Guam, Wake Island, Midway, Thailand and Malaya (due to time zone differences, some are recorded as occurring on December 8).
Pearl Harbor was just a single part of a larger campaign by the Japanese to dominate the Pacific. This strategy proved largely successful over the following year, with only the naval station at Pearl Harbor and Midway managing to resist Japanese control during the Second World War.
The reason this myth persists is that the attack on Pearl Harbor was the most devastating of the assaults. It caused the highest number of American casualties that day and brought the reality of war directly to the American public.
Japanese-Americans were the only ones detained after the attack
The internment of Japanese-Americans is well known and leads many to believe they were the only citizens detained after Pearl Harbor. This myth grew to its standing today because of the harsher treatment Japanese-Americans faced.
Following the attack, more than 3,000 individuals were arrested by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the G-2 unit within the US Army and the Office of Naval Intelligence for subversive activity. This included Japanese-Americans, along with people of Italian and German descent.
Over the course of World War II, around 120,000 Japanese-American citizens were sent to internment camps and approximately 11,000 German-Americans were interned, as well. An estimated 600,000 people of Italian descent were kept under restrictions.
A quick and decisive response by the United States
The idea that the US government and military responded to the devastating attack quickly and decisively is a popular one, but it’s a myth. In the months following what took place, the country suffered multiple defeats in the Pacific region.
This myth may have started when a rumor spread throughout the country on December 8, 1941, that the US Navy was in pursuit of the Japanese fleet. This is false, with Gen. Douglas MacArthur actually pleading for more naval assistance. In reality, a telegram was sent to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, asking for assistance and submarines to target Japanese vessels. This went unanswered and is believed to have led to the fall of the Philippines.
The first major offensive by the US occurred in February 1942, when the Pacific Fleet launched attacks on the Marshall and Gilbert Islands. Before these raids, the last successful engagement had occurred prior to Pearl Harbor.
Pearl Harbor convinced the United States to join World War II
The most common myth is that the attack on Pearl Harbor propelled the United States into World War II and turned the tide on the Axis Powers. A closer look, however, shows this isn’t quite true.
Before the assault, America was largely isolationist and unwilling to become embroiled in another European conflict. Franklin D. Roosevelt presented a declaration against Japan to the US Congress, which passed with overwhelming support. Thus, the nation was propelled only into the Pacific War as a result of Pearl Harbor – not the Second World War as a whole.
More from us: Tuskegee Airmen: The African-American Pilots Who Broke Barriers in World War II
Want to become a trivia master? Sign up for our War History Fact of the Day newsletter!
America only became involved in the European War on December 11, the date Italy and Germany declared war on the US.
Leave a Comment